Please help design a simple survey HIT

Please help design this HIT. The HIT will consist of a photo of a vintage magazine cover. Would $1 for the HIT and $1 for each bonus be appropriate? Would you change any of the text? The draft HIT text is:

Here is a photo of a vintage magazine cover we wish to improve and modernize. Please make three design recommendations to improve this cover, and explain the reasoning behind each of your recommendations.​

A small bonus given for appropriate responses. An additional bonus will be given for recommendations I end up using in my work.​

 

perhaps some examples of what that actually means in this context in the instructions

'what do good suggestions look like?'

what is a "design recommendation" 1-2 sentences with 3-4 sentences of explanation? more? less?

 

Does this make it better? I think I'll put something similar right in the HIT:

<positive-example>
<p>Main title should use a Cooper Black font. Cooper Black grabs attention and has a retro look.</p>
<p>This is a good recommendation because it's specific, thought out, and explained.</p>
</positive-example>

<negative-example>
<p>It should look more like Elle magazine.</p>
<p>This is not a good recommendation because it's not specific and not explained.</p>
</negative-example>

 

yeah, like that.

On top of perhaps a list of presented categories where common suggestions can be from made: "consider any and all of the following factors when making your recommendations: fonts, font size, contrast, moving various elements around cover, color changes ..." etc etc.

 

Thank you, that's great! I'll post the HIT here (if allowed) later.

 

I have it posted, hidden. I don't know how to view or link to the HIT, sorry. Depending on responses, I might do more tomorrow.

redesignProject1Cover

Description: Suggest improvements to a magazine cover
Keywords: survey layout design font graphics
Qualification Requirement(s):
Location is one of AU, CA, DO, GB, US

HIT Approval Rate (%) for all Requesters' HITs greater than 25

Number of Assignments per task: 4
Reward per Assignment: $1.00
Batch expires on: October 02, 2020 2:37 AM PDT (Friday) Extend this batch
Assignment duration: 1 hour
Auto Approval Delay: 2 days

 

Received one wonderful submission, one ok submission, and two duds. Accepted all of them, paying a $1 and a $2 bonus.

Just posted another batch of 4, locked out previous submitters.

Think I'll make one up for the magazine contents page later today.